Article By Gary S. Wolfe, The Wolfe Law Group –
Tax Evasion and High-priced Real Estate
On Jan 13, 2016 the New York Times reported that the US Treasury Department will start tracking secret buyers of luxury real estate in New York City (residences over $3m) and Miami-Dade County (residences over $1m) under a new US Treasury Dept initiative effective March 2016-August 2016. If Treasury Dept finds many sales involving suspicious money they would develop permanent reporting requirements across America.
The Treasury Dept initiative is intended to disclose the real owners who make all-cash purchases thru shell companies that shield purchaser identities (shell cos. include: limited liability cos., partnerships and other entities). It is part of a broader US effort to increase the focus on money laundering in real estate.
According to the Treasury Dept. foreign (and other) purchasers use shell companies, pay all-cash, for luxury real estate, which becomes “a safe haven in the US for their money”.
The US Government is requiring title insurance companies (which are involved in virtually all sales) to discover the identities of buyers and submit the information to the Treasury, which will then put the information into a database for law enforcement. According to the New York Times investigation, real estate professionals (especially in the luxury market) know little about their buyers and until now, were not legally required to identify them.
According to the NY Times, nearly 1/2 of the homes nationwide are purchased using shell companies (and in Manhattan and Los Angeles the figure is higher).
According to the NY Times, condominiums at Time Warner Center were found to have a number of hidden owners, who had been subject of investigations including: Russian Senators, British Financier(s), a Former Governor from Colombia, a businessman tied to the Malaysia Prime Minister and in Boca Raton, Florida a condominium tied to Mexico’s top housing official (now running for Governing of the Mexico Southern State of Oaxaca).
Money Laundering is the disguise of the nature or other origin of funds. It includes the transmutation of tax evasion proceeds into personal assets or 3rd party distributions. Money laundering is a felony with a 20-year jail term (18 USC 1956, 1957. If the funds are transferred by wire transfer or mail, each is a separate 20-year felony (wire fraud 18 USC 1343, mail fraud 18 USC 1341).
Taxpayers who either commit tax crimes 4 separate felonies for tax evasion/ total 16 years in jail ( see IRC 7201 tax evasion, 5 years in jail, IRC Sec. 7212 obstruct tax collection, 3 years in jail, 18 USC 371 conspiracy to commit tax evasion, 5 years in jail, or fail to intentionally file tax returns IRC 7206 ,3 years in jail) or who conspire to commit tax evasion with another (known as a Klein conspiracy) face 5 years in jail.
The tax involved may be any tax due: income, employment, estate, gift or excise taxes (see US Dept of Justice, Criminal Tax Manual Chapter 25, 25.03(2)(a). Under the money laundering statutes the IRS is authorized to assess a penalty in an amount equal to the greater of the financial proceeds received from the fraudulent activity or $10, 000 (18 USC 1956 (b). This authority is granted by statute to the IRS and is enforced either by civil penalty or civil lawsuit.
Violation of statutes for mail fraud, wire fraud, and money laundering are punishable by monetary penalties, as well as civil and criminal forfeitures (See 18 USC 981 (a) (1) (A) which permits property involved in a transaction that violates the money laundering statutes 1956, 1957, 1960 to be civilly forfeited).
For those US taxpayers who either commit tax evasion, are involved with international tax evasion (with foreign persons) and money laundering (i.e. use the tax evasion proceeds to buy assets e.g.. real estate) they face criminal prosecution for tax evasion (16 years in jail for tax crimes i.e. 4 separate tax felonies), money laundering (20 years in jail), and wire/mail fraud (20 years in jail each).
In the US Supreme Court case Pasquantino (544 US 349/2005), the Court held that a foreign government has a valuable property right in collecting taxes, and that if the tax evasion proceeds are used to purchase assets the parties involved face criminal prosecution for tax crimes and money laundering, wire/mail fraud.
Under US laws, a violation of the money laundering statutes includes a financial transaction involving the proceeds of a specified unlawful activity (SUA), i.e. a “predicate offense” with the intent to:
1) Promote that activity;
2) Violate IRC sec. 7201 (willful attempt to evade tax);
3) Violate IRC sec. 7206 (which criminalizes false and fraudulent statements made to the IRS).
Under Pasquantino, the court held that “international tax evasion” (taxes due to a foreign governments) is a predicate offense (as well as taxes due the US or State governments), for money laundering and may be criminal prosecuted for all of the above (i.e. tax evasion, money laundering, mail/wire fraud). In Pasquantino the unpaid Canadian excise taxes and the purchase of assets (with those proceeds) are tax fraud, which satisfy the SUA requirement for money laundering and may include criminal prosecution for wire/mail fraud.
For More Information Contact
THE WOLFE LAW GROUP
Gary S. Wolfe
A Professional Law Corporation
6303 Wilshire Blvd., Suite 201
Los Angeles, CA, 90048
Tel: 323-782-9139 Fax: 323-782-9289